【測速】Ping值與順暢度的問題

[ALF991]

想請問各位大大，Ping遊戲伺服器的數值可以代表連線品質嗎?

我是使用Hinet FTTB 2M/10M申請固定IP服務
連到國外的免費伺服器玩，Ping值穩定的保持在186ms左右
但是自從該遊戲推出了Hinet國內企業固定ip的跳板服務以後(要收錢)
普通Hinet用戶玩遊戲就會開始lag，但是ping值不變

但是我詢問使用其他isp的玩家卻沒有這個情況...

後來我用實驗室電腦開啟VNC做網路跳板，封包從學網=>國外
Ping遊戲伺服器的Ping值多了20~40ms，但是遊戲遊玩起來
卻順暢很多，順暢度與該遊戲推出固IP跳板之前的順暢度差不多

反應給架站者時，架站者回應

Ping值無法完全代表可以連線順暢，
我說過會LAG的 (尤其是中華電信)
改用固定制ADSL就不會LAG了 (當然專線、FTTB專業型或企業型也跟固定制ADSL屬於同樣等級)

至於您說的FTTB 10M/2M 固定IP
這跟普通的ADSL是同等級的


看了以後我覺得很納悶...
如果Ping值不能代表線路的反應速度
那麼線路順暢的基準點在哪呢?
麻煩請各位大大幫我解惑一下

另外，可以請各位大大們有企業型固定IP的可以幫忙測一下線路嗎?
網站為www.icearea.net

這是我的測試圖，這張為FTTB 2M/10M申請固定IP服務


這張為FTTB 2M/10M 固定IP掛學網VNC當跳板的連線數值
請看倒數兩個的Ping結果

[chw88]

4M固定ip
Ping www.icearea.net [209.62.13.146] with 32 bytes of data:

Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=208ms TTL=45
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=208ms TTL=45
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=209ms TTL=45
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=209ms TTL=45

Ping statistics for 209.62.13.146:
Packets: Sent = 4, Received = 4, Lost = 0 (0% loss),
Approximate round trip times in milli-seconds:
Minimum = 208ms, Maximum = 209ms, Average = 208ms


2M PPPOE
Pinging www.icearea.net [209.62.13.146] with 32 bytes of data:

Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=206ms TTL=47
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=205ms TTL=47
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=205ms TTL=47
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=205ms TTL=47

Ping statistics for 209.62.13.146:
Packets: Sent = 4, Received = 4, Lost = 0 (0% loss),
Approximate round trip times in milli-seconds:
Minimum = 205ms, Maximum = 206ms, Average = 205ms

FTTB
Pinging www.icearea.net [209.62.13.146] with 32 bytes of data:

Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=188ms TTL=45
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=187ms TTL=45
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=187ms TTL=45
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=188ms TTL=45

Ping statistics for 209.62.13.146:
Packets: Sent = 4, Received = 4, Lost = 0 (0% loss),
Approximate round trip times in milli-seconds:
Minimum = 187ms, Maximum = 188ms, Average = 187ms


以上為瞬間值，以上hinet出國的routing相同，用winmtr看比較準...

[HCG]

Seednet 4M/1M

Pinging www.icearea.net [209.62.13.146] with 32 bytes of data:

Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=269ms TTL=49
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=276ms TTL=49
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=288ms TTL=49
Reply from 209.62.13.146: bytes=32 time=277ms TTL=49

Ping statistics for 209.62.13.146:
Packets: Sent = 4, Received = 4, Lost = 0 (0% loss),
Approximate round trip times in milli-seconds:
Minimum = 269ms, Maximum = 288ms, Average = 277ms

我的 ping 一直有點高，原因還不清楚。

[JLurker]

改其他網路公司的12M/1M比較能解決問題吧?

[joe.oo]

ping 跟 traceroute 是用 ICMP 協定,

Hinet 把 ICMP 封包的 routing 弄得很漂亮, 讓你看得很很爽.
但是, 其它類的封包走的 routing 不一定是一樣的.
(Hinet 機房無能的小鬼不小心說漏嘴)
這樣就可以, 暗地裏限制頻寬.